Part III: Argu­ment from Design or the Tele­olo­gic­al Argument

Categories: God's existence
Keywords: Science and Faith

Where does the order and har­mony of the uni­verse come from? Is it pos­sible that everything just happened by chance and evolved? Is there mean­ing behind the design and pur­pose­ful­ness that sur­rounds us?

The peacock shown in the picture brings to mind beauty and elegance with its spread tail feathers. Is there a mind behind its design?

1 Intro­duc­tion

Although Kant rejec­ted the valid­ity of the tra­di­tion­al proofs for God’s exist­ence, he admit­ted that:

This proof will always deserve to be treated with respect. It is the old­est, the clearest and most in con­form­ity with human reas­on…. We have noth­ing to say against the reas­on­able­ness and util­ity of this line of argu­ment, but wish, on the con­trary, to com­mend and encour­age it.

This argu­ment is built on a very basic and obvi­ous obser­va­tion of man:

2 There Is Order and Har­mony in Nature

If we look around we see there is a very com­plex and well fit­ting arrange­ment every­where and in the uni­verse everything hap­pens in such a won­der­ful way which provides a very friendly sur­round­ing for the har­mo­ni­ous struc­tures, life and man. We see a mar­vel­lous unity and con­cord in nature. The whole uni­verse is a com­plex sys­tem, con­sist­ing of strongly cor­rel­ated and con­nec­ted parts, sub­jects to exact laws, devel­op­ing togeth­er in an inter­de­pend­ent way towards a spe­cif­ic purpose.

It would be too long here to list the fields (even without giv­ing details) in which sci­ence clearly shows the evid­ences of reg­u­lar­ity, order and har­mony. There are oth­er books (or rather lib­rar­ies) which com­plete this task. The one who deals with it will recog­nise it in every part of the remote macro-universe and in the enig­mat­ic beha­viour of the micro-universe, in the com­plex struc­tures of the inor­gan­ic and organ­ic mat­ter, in the world of the cell and bio­lo­gic­al pro­cesses, in the beha­viour of anim­als or the dance of bees, in the com­pos­i­tion of the human eye or the well co-ordinated func­tion­ing of oth­er organs.

Even if some can regard the world from the oppos­ite dir­ec­tion and observe rather imper­fec­tion, dis­har­mony, dis­cord or the exist­ence of phys­ic­al evil, nat­ur­al calam­it­ies, oth­ers draw the con­clu­sion from the evol­u­tion­ary view that nature is ruled by cruel struggle for sur­viv­al and devel­op­ment is always pos­sible through the oppres­sion of the weak one, there always still remains a large bal­ance on the oth­er side: reg­u­lar­ity, order and har­mony is obvi­ously present in the uni­verse, life and man finds the best pro­tec­tion even in severe conditions.

3 Acci­dent­al Purposefulness?

The coin­cid­ences “by chance” are too well tuned that we can explain them by “chance”. Chance is not an explan­a­tion but renoun­cing to explan­a­tion. Sci­ent­ists explain nat­ur­al phe­nom­ena by assum­ing that the effects have their causes. Gen­er­ally there are no doubts in apply­ing this prin­ciple in the case of those phe­nom­ena for which man has already found a cer­tain explan­a­tion, but there are some dif­fi­cult ques­tions for which sci­ence has­n’t found an answer yet. If they are more com­plex ques­tions, why should we give up the logic­al infer­ence that they need more com­plex explan­a­tion and not just the con­trary, the chance or chaos which is accep­ted as the simplest?

3.1 Lim­it­a­tions of Evol­u­tion­ary Theory

Does the the­ory of evol­u­tion provide a sat­is­fact­ory explanation?

Many claim that the the­ory of evol­u­tion gives the explan­a­tion for the devel­op­ment of the uni­verse and life, instead of God. But there are many oth­er ser­i­ous sci­ent­ists who testi­fy that just the very oppos­ite is true. Even from the evol­u­tion­ary stand­point the uni­verse does­n’t show dis­order but a mar­vel­lous design which will lead the hon­est sci­ent­ist to a humble won­der­ing that everything happened in such a well adjus­ted way that, des­pite so many hindrances and great gaps between the dif­fer­ent steps, it was pos­sible to reach the appear­ance of life and at the top of evol­u­tion man with con­science who can admire today all these things. Isn’t it rather a clear evid­ence for a highest intel­li­gent design?

Fol­low­ing the for­mu­la­tion of Wil­li­am Paley[1] con­cern­ing a man who found a watch, and con­cluded that it must have been made by a watch­maker, Voltaire resumed:

If a watch proves the exist­ence of a watch­maker but the uni­verse does not prove the exist­ence of a great Archi­tect, then I con­sent to be called a fool.

Now, if some­body finds an auto­mated fact­ory that pro­duces watches without any human inter­ven­tion, will not he think that it must have been designed by a high­er intel­li­gence? In the same way, sci­entif­ic the­or­ies will nev­er show that everything can explain itself but rather they will make even clear­er how won­der­ful this world is and everything func­tions in a fit­ting order, there­fore it requires a more intel­li­gent super­nat­ur­al Creator.

If a watch proves the exist­ence of a watch­maker but the uni­verse does not prove the exist­ence of a great Archi­tect, then I con­sent to be called a fool. (Voltaire)

The fact is that the the­ory of evol­u­tion, at least at the present stage, can give a suf­fi­cient answer neither for the pur­pose­ful devel­op­ment, because it con­tains great gaps in the chain of explan­a­tions, nor for the ori­gin of the uni­verse, the ori­gin of life, ori­gin of spe­cies or the ori­gin of human spir­it. Even if many people hope that it is a ques­tion of time and once man­kind will find explan­a­tion for everything, there are ser­i­ous reas­ons to doubt it.

But even if we find a suf­fi­cient explan­a­tion of how some­thing happened, it does­n’t mean that it happened by itself. Even the best sci­entif­ic explan­a­tion or the most com­pre­hens­ive or gen­er­al the­ory would not explain why the nat­ur­al laws are just these and why just these pro­cesses must hap­pen. Sci­ence can explain many details of the cos­mos but it can not grasp ques­tions that are out­side its frame.

3.2 The Intel­li­gent Designer

For the reas­ons above, the pur­pose­ful­ness of the uni­verse can be sat­is­fact­or­ily explained by the exist­ence of a tran­scend­ent intel­li­gent Design­er in whom we can believe, leav­ing no room for any oth­er explanation.

Nat­ur­al phe­nom­ena do not posses intel­li­gence in them­selves and we can not speak about their inten­tion­al act­ing so their pur­pose­ful act­ing can be explained only by the con­trol of a wise being hav­ing free will. This argu­ment does not prove in itself the infin­ity and per­fec­tion of the Design­er, but it shows at least that He is bey­ond the uni­verse and is a super­i­or Mind who dir­ects everything towards the ful­fil­ment of a cer­tain aim. We can get to know also some­thing about this aim, at least that everything is guided so that humans own­ing mind and free will able to love come into existence.

Sci­ence can only be cre­ated by those who are thor­oughly imbued with the aspir­a­tion toward truth and under­stand­ing. This source of feel­ing, how­ever, springs from the sphere of reli­gion. To this there also belongs the faith in the pos­sib­il­ity that the reg­u­la­tions val­id for the world of exist­ence are ration­al, that is, com­pre­hens­ible to reas­on. I can­not con­ceive of a genu­ine sci­ent­ist without that pro­found faith. The situ­ation may be expressed by an image: sci­ence without reli­gion is lame, reli­gion without sci­ence is blind. (Albert Ein­stein)


Footnotes

  1. Wil­li­am Paley (July 1743 – 25 May 1805) was an Eng­lish Anglic­an cler­gy­man, Chris­ti­an apo­lo­gist, philo­soph­er, and util­it­ari­an. He is best known for his nat­ur­al theo­logy expos­i­tion of the tele­olo­gic­al argu­ment for the exist­ence of God in his 1802 work Nat­ur­al Theo­logy or Evid­ences of the Exist­ence and Attrib­utes of the Deity, which made use of the watch­maker ana­logy. (Wiki­pe­dia: Wil­li­am Paley)


Wil­li­am Paley (July 1743 – 25 May 1805) was an Eng­lish Anglic­an cler­gy­man, Chris­ti­an apo­lo­gist, philo­soph­er, and util­it­ari­an. He is best known for his nat­ur­al theo­logy expos­i­tion of the tele­olo­gic­al argu­ment for the exist­ence of God in his 1802 work Nat­ur­al Theo­logy or Evid­ences of the Exist­ence and Attrib­utes of the Deity, which made use of the watch­maker ana­logy. (Wiki­pe­dia: Wil­li­am Paley)