Part IV: Argu­ments from Human Nature

Categories: God's existence

The fol­low­ing thoughts will start from the uncon­tested exist­ing real­ity, from our human nature, that all of us exper­i­ence. We want to remind you of the fact that our deep­est inten­tions and long­ings con­tain in them­selves a final aim that really can ful­fil them.

We exper­i­ence life as a con­tinu­ous search. Every goal in this world can offer only a tem­por­ary sat­is­fac­tion. This can be explained only if we accept that there is a final goal and without reach­ing it man can not be sat­is­fied with tem­por­ary solu­tions. There­fore, the ulti­mate goal of our search lies bey­ond the bound­ar­ies of this world.

A little boy enjoying playing with soap bubbles—it aptly illustrates man's unique ability to comprehend the surrounding world, to be happy and to ask questions.

1 The Ulti­mate Goal of Life, Happiness—Longing for Fulfilment

Every man struggles day by day for things he con­siders import­ant in his life. Youth struggle for suc­cess in study­ing, adults for earn­ing money for main­tain­ing them­selves and their fam­il­ies. Some invest a lot of time and energy in improv­ing sci­ence or serving the bene­fit of soci­ety in oth­er areas. These are good things in them­selves but what is the final sense of all these? Although people can be sat­is­fied by these claims find­ing tem­por­al joy nev­er­the­less they can not find final ful­fil­ment and secur­ity in them. An earth­quake can anni­hil­ate everything that a man builds up all his life, a death of a beloved fam­ily mem­ber can drive some­body into depres­sion. There are many cases when man is forced to be con­fron­ted with the finite­ness of his life and of the things of this world.

There is also anoth­er out­look on life, which pro­claims amuse­ment and enjoy­ment as the real sense of life. Every hon­est man can recog­nise that this think­ing and man­ner of life causes people to go empty los­ing the abil­ity to appre­ci­ate the actu­al val­ues of life. This ideo­logy is the best source of licentious­ness, immor­al­ity and aggres­sion. Con­sequently this can not be the real aim of life either.

1.1 Sol­id Foundations

Every­one wants to have a sol­id found­a­tion on which to rely. What could this be? Jesus Christ said:

Do not lay up for yourselves treas­ures on earth, where moth and rust des­troy and where thieves break in and steal… (Mat­thew 6:19)

Even if someone does not accept him as Son of God, nev­er­the­less can see that His words are true. How many people find­ing mater­i­al wealth or great repu­ta­tion com­mit­ted sui­cide? How many of them who put their whole trust in man became human wrecks after get­ting dis­ap­point­ing in them? What can a man dis­cov­er in this world at all that could sup­ply abso­lute secur­ity for him? Who could give sat­is­fact­ory answers to the greatest ques­tions of man­kind? Jesus fin­ishes his state­ment like this:

…but lay up for yourselves treas­ures in heav­en, where neither moth nor rust des­troys and where thieves do not break in and steal. … But seek first the king­dom of God and his right­eous­ness, and all these things will be added to you. (Mat­thew 6:20 & 33)

1.2 The Impossib­il­ity of Achiev­ing Ful­fill­ment in Tran­si­ent Things

Every per­son has the right to find the aim of his life, joy and love. Though many people try to repress this claim, yet it seems that man­kind searches the ful­fil­ment and those who failed to find their aim sink in them­selves. Thus long­ing for full­ness is a nat­ur­al human need but find­ing it is logic­ally and prac­tic­ally impossible if there is not some­thing or someone pos­sess­ing that full­ness in itself. Since as far as we know man is the being of the highest level in the uni­verse, it can be logic­ally excluded in advance that his long­ing for full­ness could ever be com­pleted merely by mater­i­al things—which are on lower level. Of course one can find joy in oth­er people or mater­i­al things, too. This joy, how­ever, derived from its nature, is only pro­vi­sion­al and par­tial and the quest for full­ness based on them is a self-cheat and illusion.

… long­ing for ful­fill­ment is a nat­ur­al human need …

A per­son is unable to ful­fil anoth­er per­son com­pletely since they stand on the same level and they “struggle” with the same needs. Thus the exist­ence of an abso­lute being above man able to com­plete his needs is a prime neces­sity for life.

2 The Basic Need of Man for Rela­tion­ship in Love

Accord­ing to per­son­al­ist­ic philo­sophy ( e.g. Mar­tin Buber), the basic need of man is rela­tion­ship: open­ness and mutu­al love towards oth­ers. Love is the deep­est mani­fest­a­tion of the essence of our per­son­al­ity. Man, by his nature, is a social being. There­fore all the pos­sib­il­it­ies of our human nature can be real­ised not only regard­ing the indi­vidu­al but brak­ing the frame of our own exist­ence and refer­ring to our place among the oth­ers. This means that for the real­isa­tion, open­ing and ful­filling our per­son­al being a rela­tion­ship between “You and me” is indis­pens­able. Mainly our need for the oth­ers and our devo­tion to them can form in us the sense of respons­ib­il­ity and the right assess­ment of ourselves and of the oth­ers. Only relat­ing ourselves towards oth­er per­son­al beings we can attain self-reflection, self-disposition, self-consciousness and so the sense of respons­ib­il­ity. Because man has the need of being in com­munity, the main obstacle in per­fect­ing his per­son­al­ity is self-contentness, with­draw­ing in him­self. Selfish­ness can serve only appar­ently for gain­ing one’s own interests, because the one who does­n’t take into con­sid­er­a­tion the oth­er­’s needs, who does­n’t know sac­ri­fice (renounce­ment) for the oth­er one or who is mis­trust­ful towards oth­ers, isol­ates him­self from the com­munity and so isol­ates him­self just from what he is look­ing for: find­ing ful­fil­ment for his own being. A man who lives for him­self or wants to gain power over the oth­ers can not be free, only serving oth­ers can make one free. Only in devo­tion one can be sat­is­fied with his life and his realisation.

2.1 Per­fect Love

But man can see always the human lim­its: he can­not get nor give per­fect love. The love we can receive from anoth­er man will have an end when we lose him. There­fore the nat­ur­al need of man for receiv­ing etern­al love can be ful­filled only by an etern­al per­fect being who is the inex­haust­ible source of love.

Once man’s long­ing for per­fect love is ful­filled he him­self will own the source from which he will be able to give love to oth­ers. Every­body can exper­i­ence that he can­not sat­is­fy per­fectly the oth­er one by his own power because the oth­er one’s needs go bey­ond one’s human lim­its. A right rela­tion­ship with anoth­er man is pos­sible only through tak­ing into con­sid­er­a­tion his whole nature, all his needs, that often sur­pass one’s own abil­it­ies. This is the way someone has to regard the oth­er one in order to see him not only as a tool for his own hap­pi­ness but in his com­plete real­ity as a being hav­ing need for abso­lute love. In this way man’s nat­ur­al long­ing for rela­tion­ship in love can not be ful­filled per­fectly without an abso­lute source of love that is God.

3 Long­ing for Righteousness

Every­body has a nat­ur­al sense of right­eous­ness. This can be eas­ily seen by the fact that bad deeds of “enemies” are strictly assessed. People are usu­ally much more sens­it­ive towards their “enemies” than towards them­selves. We have the wish that people are treated right­eously, or at least the wish that they them­selves are right­eously treated.

Now evol­u­tion­ists try to explain this phe­nomen­on as a res­ult of com­mon life of human beings because it is advant­age­ous for the col­lect­ive to be right­eous. How­ever, the sense of right­eous­ness can­not simply devel­op, there is no more or less of it. It does not seem to be a sens­ible thought that man­kind decided at an early stage to be right­eous and con­sequently it was trans­mit­ted to the des­cend­ants. Such phe­nom­ena, abil­it­ies can­not be inher­ited but every indi­vidu­al has to decide to be right­eous or not. Secondly, right­eous­ness does not ask for being advant­age­ous for one­self or oth­ers. A right­eous deed is done inde­pend­ently of its con­sequences. So how can our long­ing for right­eous­ness be fulfilled?

Our world has always been full of unright­eous­ness and it is not real­ist­ic to think that this will com­pletely change. Fur­ther­more we are not sat­is­fied with par­tial right­eous­ness which people struggle for like politi­cians (some­times), human­ists and reli­gious people. Real all-embracing right­eous­ness that is val­id for every­one can­not be found with­in this world.

So is the long­ing for right­eous­ness only a sense­less char­ac­ter of human being or does­n’t it just hint at a tran­scend­ent being who can provide it eternally?

4 Beauty and Harmony

If the reas­on of the com­ing into exist­ence of the uni­verse and man is just the sequence of extremely rare events, where are beauty and har­mony from? Why does man have abil­it­ies that are com­pletely unne­ces­sary from the point of view of sur­viv­al and race pre­ser­va­tion? Where are the artist­ic gifts, poetry, lit­er­at­ure, and music from? If life is just a cruel struggle for sur­viv­al, where are these val­ues from and why have they survived?

There was a child who liked to paint, and indeed he painted nicely. One day he sat in his room and star­ted to paint a beau­ti­ful land­scape. After sit­ting many hours with his utensils, he became tired and went out. He looked up at the sky and at the trees and spon­tan­eously shouted out: “Oh, this is more beau­ti­ful than what I painted and I can ever paint ! But who is the one who painted all these?”

Man has a nat­ur­al wish for beauty, which reflects per­fec­tion, the ideal. Beau­ti­ful is what approaches the ideal or the per­fec­tion of itself. The rhythm of pro­por­tions, lines, col­ours, sounds does not have usu­ally mater­i­al or bio­lo­gic­al worth, even if it can be con­nec­ted, we like it because of oth­er reas­ons. We have joy when we see beau­ti­ful things because they bring us near­er to the infin­ite beauty we have wish for and we love. We like to see the wav­ing sea, the high moun­tains because they sug­gest great­ness, infin­ity, majesty. So the attract­ing power of beauty leads us to an infin­ite source, to the per­fec­tion which can sat­is­fy our long­ing for it.

4.1 The “Flower Burial”

An illus­tra­tion con­cern­ing the love of beauty, belong­ing to the nature of man:

The exped­i­tion led by Ral­ph Solecki[1] of Columbia Uni­ver­sity in the rugged Zagros Moun­tains of north­ern Iraq excav­ated in 1960 in the Shan­id­ar Cave the bones of an old Nean­ther­th­al man who died 60.000 years ago. His buri­al was pre­pared in a spe­cial way: He res­ted in a bed with bundles of woody hor­se­tail branches. Fes­toons of yar­row, hol­ly­hock, ground­sell, grape hyacinth, corn­flowers and oth­er flowers were woven among the ram­ose stems of the woody hor­se­tail. Solecki wrote about this “flower burial”:

We are brought sud­denly to the real­isa­tion that the uni­ver­sal­ity of man­kind and the love of beauty go bey­ond the bound­ar­ies of our own spe­cies. …No longer can we deny the early men the full range of human feel­ings and exper­i­ence.[2]

5 Mor­al­ity (The Argu­ment from Conscience)

Why does mor­al­ity exist and why is there a basic long­ing for good in man and why is there conscience?

5.1 There Is an Object­ive Mor­al Law

Even if some people are not aware of or con­sciously do not admit the real­ity of a uni­ver­sal mor­al law, gen­er­ally every­body agrees in some basic mor­al prin­ciples neces­sary for our life as indi­vidu­als and as collectivity.

It is true that there always exis­ted dif­fer­ences con­cern­ing the mor­al prin­ciples but these dif­fer­ences were always smal­ler than their con­sent. If some­body com­pares the mor­al teach­ings of dif­fer­ent cul­tures from dif­fer­ent times among dif­fer­ent nations, will see the great sim­il­ar­it­ies among them and the great sim­il­ar­ity to our mor­al precepts.

C. S. Lewis[3] proves in his book, The Abol­i­tion of Man, that the ancient Egyp­tians, Baby­lo­ni­ans, Hindus, Chinese, Greeks and Romans had very sim­il­ar mor­al teach­ings. In no cul­ture were treas­on, cheat­ing, impost­ors or selfish men admired. There are dif­fer­ences in dif­fer­ent cul­tures con­cern­ing the num­ber of wives in an offi­cial mar­riage, but no cul­ture has ever glor­i­fied the act of adul­tery or shown as a vir­tue to take away the wife of the oth­er man. In no cul­ture was it per­mit­ted to murder any­body without any reas­on, not even among can­ni­bals, who also have their laws and they don’t murder any­body they want either. The fact that Nazis con­sidered their supreme aim to root out some oth­er nations does­n’t show that this can be also part of the nat­ur­al law. Just the fact that we may cri­ti­cise them shows that there is a super­i­or truth in this ques­tion to which all are sub­mit­ted and by which all can be judged.

5.2 The Conscience

Let’s exam­ine the devel­op­ment of this inner law in the life of the indi­vidu­al. The real­ity of the devel­op­ment of con­science of the indi­vidu­als is observ­able from their child­hood on. This change is influ­enced by sev­er­al things but the most import­ant influ­en­cing aspect is per­son­al decision. Man can deny his con­science and every such a decision affects our inner law. They influ­ence the work of our con­science regard­ing what things and to what extent it draws our atten­tion to. This is the main reas­on of the dif­fer­ences that we see in people’s mor­al assess­ment. But these influ­en­cing per­son­al decisions do not change the real­ity of the exist­ence of a com­mon start­ing point and pur­ity of our con­science determ­ined by the object­ive law of morality.

Every­body exper­i­ences the obli­ging char­ac­ter of the word of this inner law. Even if man does not con­form to it, he knows “it should be”, “it would be good” or “it would have been good”. These inner warn­ings have super­i­or author­ity because even if I don’t like it, I must face its mes­sage. The assess­ment of the voice of con­science is at work before, dur­ing and after our actions, accus­ing or jus­ti­fy­ing us. Its uncon­di­tioned obli­ging char­ac­ter is for the pur­pose of edu­ca­tion. Its task is to cor­rect the sub­ject­ive devi­ations cre­ated by our bad motives and decisions and to dir­ect us back to the pur­ity of the object­ive and the highest good. It means that even if indi­vidu­al con­science changes in the course of time its ori­gin is shown by its task to lead people to the abso­lute truth and objectiv­ity super­i­or to them.

5.3 What Can Be the Source of the Object­ive Mor­al Law?

Can con­science be only the product of social edu­ca­tion or envir­on­ment­al influ­ence? If con­science may be only the product of these out­ward influ­ences then the strongest influ­ence, namely the par­ents’ life would always neces­sar­ily determ­ine the mor­al ori­ent­a­tion of the child as well. But a child of mur­der­er par­ents will not neces­sar­ily become a mur­der­er. For­tu­nately, we also often see young people who have not become vic­tims of the vari­ous forms of immor­al­ity offered by our mod­ern soci­ety but try to escape from it. It would not be pos­sible if also their con­science were pro­duced by the con­tem­por­ary soci­ety. That is why we think that although these aspects indeed influ­ence the form­ing of con­science of people, nev­er­the­less these ways of explan­a­tions in them­selves must be regarded as sim­pli­fic­a­tions of a com­plic­ated question.

Here we don’t intend to deal with the mater­i­al­ists’ pro­pos­al for the evol­u­tion­ary com­ing into exist­ence of human con­science. Let us only refer to the gen­er­al opin­ion of Nobel- sci­ent­ists regard­ing the enorm­ous gap between human con­science and forms of spir­itu­al beha­viour and the highest mani­fest­a­tions of instinct com­bin­a­tions of the anim­al king­dom. Since the dif­fer­ence is not just the mat­ter of the level of devel­op­ment of the same fea­tures but of unique and new qual­it­ies, the answer of the ori­gin of our con­science must be found some­where else. We have col­lec­ted some quo­ta­tions of fam­ous sci­ent­ists of this field in a sep­ar­ate part, see Sci­ent­ists con­cern­ing spirit.

If the object­ive mor­al law can not come only from the mater­i­al world through evol­u­tion­ary pro­cesses, nor can it be explained by some indi­vidu­al or col­lect­ive psych­ic­al influ­ence of the soci­ety, then it must have a source exter­i­or to our world. This super­i­or Law­giver must be someone whose nature is in per­fect accord­ance with the mor­al laws he gives. We call this per­fect, supreme and per­son­al Law­giver God.

5.4 Oth­er Argu­ments Based on Morality

In a later peri­od of his life Kant rejec­ted the tra­di­tion­al proofs and con­sidered that the exist­ence of God and the immor­tal­ity of soul were mat­ters of faith, not of reas­on, which, he claimed, is lim­ited to sen­sa­tion. Out of many argu­ments he accep­ted only the mor­al argu­ment, but not in the form presen­ted above. Kant reasoned that every­body’s aim is per­fect hap­pi­ness and every­body should seek the sum­mum bonum (highest good) by obey­ing the mor­al law. But mor­tal men can not reach a pro­por­tion­ate hap­pi­ness through striv­ing for mor­al­ity, there­fore there must exist a per­fect God who will reward us with per­fec­tion after death.

“The argu­ment from dam­na­tion” giv­en by Peter Ber­ger in his Rumour of Angels is in fact a neg­at­ive ver­sion of the reas­on­ing with mor­al­ity. His idea is thought-provoking even if it is not a strong argu­ment because it assumes a pos­it­ive turn of mind, accord­ing to which every­body must receive what he deserves. It starts from the fact that some deeds like slavery, gen­o­cide or holo­caust are so evil that they deserve not only an earthly pun­ish­ment but a super­nat­ur­al con­dem­na­tion, oth­er­wise there would be no justice.

6 The Free­dom of Human Will

The free­dom of will means the accom­plish­ment of acts con­sidered the most expedi­ent on the base of one’s own dis­cre­tion, obey­ing his own sense of respons­ib­il­ity without any extern­al force. Thus it can be con­cluded that the free­dom of one’s ideas and decisions can not be determ­ined by any mor­al, bio­lo­gic­al, chem­ic­al or phys­ic­al law nor can it be described by any for­mula. Man can always weigh con­sciously the choice from among numer­ous pos­sib­il­it­ies of actions while the mat­ter behaves always accord­ing to the qual­it­ies by which it is determ­ined. Man is able to form him­self by his decisions, he is able to devel­op his abil­it­ies and he has the pos­sib­il­ity to decide oppos­ing his instincts, dis­pos­i­tion and fea­tures. Moreover man is able to make the mater­i­al world serve him through his mind both in good or bad dir­ec­tions and he is able to inter­fere into the law of nature though some­times at the expense of grave con­sequences. All these show expli­citly that the attrib­utes of human intel­li­gence and will are in a rad­ic­al oppos­i­tion to the char­ac­ter­ist­ics of mat­ter. So it is obvi­ous that the reas­on for the exist­ence of the free will can­not be found in mat­ter which is unable to act in a reas­on­able and pur­pose­ful way by itself. The ori­gin­at­or of intel­li­gence and will has to pos­sess these fea­tures as well and to be able to pass them on. It implies that the reas­on which caused—and so possesses—the intel­li­gence and free­dom of will has to be a per­son, too, for these attrib­utes pre­sup­pose con­scious­ness and can be con­nec­ted only to a person.

7 The Dynam­ism of Human Spir­it (Long­ing for the Infinite)

The con­scious phe­nom­ena in the case of anim­als are always the product of inward and out­ward inform­a­tion tak­ing place at the present moment. The human self-awareness is not motiv­ated only by instincts or inform­a­tion com­ing from out­side, which we can see from sev­er­al spir­itu­al activ­it­ies. The life and interest of anim­als are determ­ined and com­plete in the frame of their existence.

The real­isa­tion of human life is char­ac­ter­ised by the unlim­ited open­ness and free­dom of our know­ledge and aspirations.

Man is inter­ested and open not only towards his own every­day life, but he asks some basic ques­tions con­cern­ing the ori­gin and final reas­on of his exist­ence: “Who am I? Where do I come from? Where do I go? What is my place in the sur­round­ing world?” Fur­ther­more, he has also ques­tions con­cern­ing the whole exist­ence: “What is the world? Where did it come from? What is the truth? How can I get to know it? What is the final aim of the whole exist­ence?” Ques­tions like these show that human mind strives to under­stand the total­ity of the infin­ite exist­ence. It sur­passes the senses and con­cepts and wants to grasp the total exist­ence. Man’s per­son­al­ity con­tains the long­ing to break out from the lim­its of space and time. Human spir­it does not con­nect only to the present point of space and time. People can be in spir­it (in thoughts) at any point of space and time of the world, which shows that our mind is not depend­ent only on mat­ter. Man’s spir­itu­al activ­ity and intel­lec­tu­al ori­ent­a­tion and motiv­a­tion go bey­ond the finite world and are dir­ec­ted towards the infin­ite and com­plete reality.

This nat­ur­al abil­ity and striv­ing of man must have an object that is bey­ond the sen­su­al exper­i­ence of real­ity. Oth­er­wise this long­ing for the infin­ite would be base­less. How could man real­ise the finite­ness and imper­fec­tion if the infin­ite and per­fec­tion did not exist?

8 Long­ing for Immortality

Life is a great sur­prise. I don’t see why death should not be an even great­er one. (Vladi­mir Nabokov[4])

Man is the only liv­ing being who is aware of his death.

The long­ing for immor­tal­ity is at least as old as the human civil­isa­tion. We can see already in the earli­est cul­tures that people pre­pared and equipped their dead care­fully for their life in the oth­er world. Dif­fer­ent tribes and nations had dif­fer­ent buri­al cus­toms but usu­ally all of them reflect some kind of belief in the exist­ence after death.

Life is a great sur­prise. I don’t see why death should not be an even great­er one. (Vladi­mir Nabokov)

This shows that the belief in life after death is so closely con­nec­ted with the nature of man that we might con­sider this fact as hav­ing a real base. The fact that many people nowadays accept so eas­ily the idea of anni­hil­a­tion often shows rather the lack of think­ing than a deep conviction.

If we accept that human spir­it is immor­tal then it can not be the product of evol­u­tion­ary pro­cesses (which lead only to per­ish­able things) but sup­poses an immor­tal Creator.

9 The Argu­ment of Uni­ver­sal Consent

Reli­gi­os­ity, the idea of the exist­ence of a kind of super­i­or author­ity has prov­ably accom­pan­ied the his­tory of man­kind every­where in the world for mil­len­nia, from the earli­est ages up to nowadays. People’s belief in God could not be dis­proved or abol­ished even by lots of rad­ic­al social, cul­tur­al and ideo­lo­gic­al changes. How could a sup­pos­i­tion have sur­vived in spite of all these changes abso­lutely base­less and unreal?

It is true that there has always been a large vari­ety of dis­figured reli­gious beliefs and super­sti­tions and many people have accep­ted Poly­the­ism, Dual­ism, Pan­the­ism or oth­er kinds of erro­neous under­stand­ings. But this fact does not dis­prove our argu­ment because by uni­ver­sal con­sent we do not under­stand the way people exactly under­stood deity and what they believed about it, but we speak about the gen­er­al belief in the exist­ence of a super­i­or being or beings on whom the mater­i­al world and man him­self are depend­ent. Even if people often dis­tor­ted their recog­ni­tion, the com­mon ger­min­al truth from their belief can­not be explained in anoth­er way than that it is the res­ult of the nat­ur­al com­mon sense of man that draws con­clu­sions from the exist­ing evidences.

9.1 The Ori­gins of Reli­gious Faith and Atheism

There are many explan­a­tions for the ori­gin and the uni­ver­sal­ity of reli­gion but gen­er­ally anthro­po­lo­gists and philo­soph­ers of reli­gion agree about the above stated con­sent of man­kind. Moreover, there is a good deal of pos­it­ive evid­ence for sup­port­ing the the­ory that the first reli­gion of man­kind was Mono­the­ism and dur­ing the his­tory it degen­er­ated instead of pro­gress­ing. But even if it became in many cases very obscure, the core of the ori­gin­al truth was not com­pletely abolished.

Con­cern­ing athe­ism, we can not say the same. His­tory proves that athe­ist­ic philo­sophy is a “mod­ern achieve­ment” and it is not char­ac­ter­ist­ic in the nor­mal human soci­ety but is a rather abnor­mal reac­tion of a rel­at­ively few num­ber of people. Its present form is closely con­nec­ted with the sud­den and intense improve­ment of human know­ledge by mod­ern sci­ence from the last cen­tury on and although sci­ence has really developed con­sid­er­ably in this peri­od, it should hon­estly be acknow­ledged that the greatest ques­tions of life are still open. From the writ­ings of many ancient so-called athe­ists we can see that they were rather against the abuse of reli­gion and against the rejec­tion of ration­al­ity than against the exist­ence of all kinds of divin­ity. In some cases it could be con­sidered as an admir­able vir­tue of the non­con­form­ists who do not adhere on the mind of the large mass just because of the fact that they are in the major­ity, if their con­tri­bu­tion has real bases and have a super­i­or aim like uncov­er­ing the truth and a bet­ter way of life. But this is not the case with athe­ism where many examples show rather the con­trary. There­fore neither the ancient nor the mod­ern oppon­ents of reli­gion can uproot the belief in God which is so deeply implanted in man’s heart.

10 Sci­ent­ists on the Human Spirit

What do sci­ent­ists say about the human spir­it? Is the human spir­it merely the res­ult of the evol­u­tion of matter?

Sev­er­al mater­i­al­ist sci­ent­ists try to explain the highest spir­itu­al pro­cesses, includ­ing self-awareness and con­scious­ness, as being only the res­ult of bio­chem­ic­al reac­tions. They are called reduc­tion­ists, because they reduce the whole real­ity to the level of mater­i­al pro­cesses. But there are many oth­er sci­ence experts who do not belong to this cat­egory, who are aware of the lim­its of sci­ence, who speak about “the won­der and mys­tery of the human self with its spir­itu­al val­ues, with its cre­ativ­ity, and with its unique­ness for each of us”, like John C. Eccles[5], Nobel prize win­ner and neuroscientist.


Footnotes

  1. Ral­ph Stefan Solecki (Octo­ber 15, 1917 – March 20, 2019) was an Amer­ic­an archae­olo­gist. He was a pro­fess­or at Columbia Uni­ver­sity from 1959 to 1988. His most fam­ous excav­a­tions were car­ried out at the Neander­th­al site in Shan­id­ar Cave in the Kur­distan region of Iraq.
  2. Sci­ence 190/1975; It should be noted here that it is sci­en­tific­ally dis­puted wheth­er Neander­th­al man was a sep­ar­ate spe­cies or a sub­spe­cies of Homo sapiens.
  3. Clive Staples Lewis (29 Novem­ber 1898 – 22 Novem­ber 1963) was a Brit­ish writer, lit­er­ary schol­ar, thinker, and theologian.
  4. Vladi­mir Nabokov (ori­gin­ally Vladi­mir Vladi­mirovich Nabokov, April 22, 1899 – July 2, 1977) was a Russian-born Amer­ic­an writer, trans­lat­or, and crit­ic. He wrote in his nat­ive lan­guage and in Eng­lish. See more: Wiki­pe­dia: Vladi­mir Nabokov
  5. Sir John Carew Eccles (27 Janu­ary 1903 – 2 May 1997) was an Aus­trali­an neuro­physiolo­gist and philo­soph­er who won the 1963 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medi­cine for his work on the synapse.


Ral­ph Stefan Solecki (Octo­ber 15, 1917 – March 20, 2019) was an Amer­ic­an archae­olo­gist. He was a pro­fess­or at Columbia Uni­ver­sity from 1959 to 1988. His most fam­ous excav­a­tions were car­ried out at the Neander­th­al site in Shan­id­ar Cave in the Kur­distan region of Iraq.

Sci­ence 190/1975; It should be noted here that it is sci­en­tific­ally dis­puted wheth­er Neander­th­al man was a sep­ar­ate spe­cies or a sub­spe­cies of Homo sapiens.

Clive Staples Lewis (29 Novem­ber 1898 – 22 Novem­ber 1963) was a Brit­ish writer, lit­er­ary schol­ar, thinker, and theologian.

Vladi­mir Nabokov (ori­gin­ally Vladi­mir Vladi­mirovich Nabokov, April 22, 1899 – July 2, 1977) was a Russian-born Amer­ic­an writer, trans­lat­or, and crit­ic. He wrote in his nat­ive lan­guage and in Eng­lish. See more: Wiki­pe­dia: Vladi­mir Nabokov

Sir John Carew Eccles (27 Janu­ary 1903 – 2 May 1997) was an Aus­trali­an neuro­physiolo­gist and philo­soph­er who won the 1963 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medi­cine for his work on the synapse.